Why is the clip funny?
The clip is made to
make people laugh at Will. He throws the Frisbee in the first place to try and
impress Carly and the rest of the girls however it ends up hitting the girl in
the wheelchair. The clip is funny because of how awkward the situation becomes.
Everyone is watching Will as he tries to deal with what he’s done and it is
made more awkward because the girl is disabled and therefore he handles the
situation differently than he usually would.
How is the disabled girl being represented?
The disabled girl is viewed as the victim. It is made out that because
of her disability, everyone should feel more sympathy for her. The girl is,
unfortunately for Will, represented as the target of a trying to get the girls
involved in the game. Because of the reaction of Donovan and the other lads
playing football, the girl is represented.
Are we meant to laugh at the disabled person?
The disabled girl was unable to move
out of the way of the Frisbee whereas a person who isn’t in a wheelchair may
have moved. As the viewer of this comedy show we are obliged to laugh at the
disabled person however some people would argue that you should laugh at the
joke itself rather than the disabled woman. If we were not supposed to laugh at
the woman, the scene wouldn't have been included because it is meant to be
funny.
Are they the 'butt' of the joke?
Will is the main butt of the joke because it is
supposed to be embarrassing for him rather than the disabled woman. It is
obvious that Neil and Jay are embarrassed because they run off from Will. Simon
being the kind person he is gets caught up in the joke and ends up getting
chased by Donovan and the other lads. Will is the centre of the joke because he
has made a fool out of himself in front of the girls.
How do you think disabled people will respond to this?
I think that disabled people shouldn’t take it to heart
because they are not the main centre of the joke. You could say they were being
used more as a prop to assist the joke as Will is the person who the audience
should be laughing at. Obviously there will be some people who find this
offensive but that will come with most comedy as somebody or something has to
be the target of the joke.
Are we as a society cultivated to think we should pity the disabled?
As society we do tend to pity the disabled however this
shouldn’t always be the case because they would want to be treated equally to
everyone else. I think that disabled people are more bothered about them being treated differently rather than them being like everyone else.
No comments:
Post a Comment